New Castle Bagels Menu

Made Fresh Daily! Due to the Avian Flu, our prices have increased. This is beyond our control. We are a small business and just trying to keep our doors open. ​

    • Bagels

    • Bagel

      $1.65

    • Baker's Dozen

      $17

    • Bialy

      $1.65

      Add Butter or Jelly - $1.50
      Add Butter & Jelly - $3.00
      Add Gourmet Cream Cheese - 3.50
      Add Cream Cheese - $3.00
      Add Peanut Butter - $3.00
      Add Sliced Lox & Cream Cheese - $9.00

    • Half Dozen

      $10.50

    • Muffins

    • Cookies

      $1.95

    • Cream Cheese 1/2lb

      $5.25

    • Cream Cheese 1lb

      $10.50

    • Gourmet Cream Cheese 1/2lb

      $7

    • Gourmet Cream Cheese 1lb

      $14

    • Muffin

      $2.50

      Muffin Varieties: Blueberry, Corn, Apple Crumb, Double Chocolate, Oatmeal Rasin

      Seasonal Muffin Varieties: Banana Nut, French Toast, Pumpkin (muffin varieties differ daily)

    • Breakfast Sandwiches

    • Bagel w/ Bacon & Cheese

      $6.50

    • Bagel w/ Boiled Ham & Cheese

      $6.50

    • Bagel w/ Sausage & Cheese

      $6.50

    • Bagel w/ Scrapple & Cheese

      $6.50

    • Bagel w/ Steak Egg & Cheese

      $9

    • Bagel w/ Taylor Ham & Cheese

      $6.50

    • Bagel w/ Turkey Bacon & Cheese

      $8

    • Bagel w/ Turkey Sausage & Cheese

      $8

    • Egg on Bagel

      $5

    • Extra Add On:

      $9

      Add extra Egg - $3.00
      Add Cheese - $2.00
      Add Fried/Raw Onions - $2.00
      Add Lettuce & Tomatoes - $2.00

    • Florida

      $8.50

      2 eggs, ham, swiss, lettuce, tomato, & mayo, on a roll/bagel/bread topped with Hot Sauce

    • French Toast

      $6.50

    • Sliced Corned Beef Egg & Cheese

      $9

    • Sliced Pastrami Egg & Cheese

      $9

    • Sliced Roast Beef Egg & Cheese

      $9

    • Sliced Turkey Egg & Cheese

      $9

    • Cream Cheese Spread Varieties:

    • Scallion, Vegetable, Cinnamon Raisin, Strawberry

    • Sliced Lox 1/2lb

      $14

    • Sliced Lox 1lb

      $28

    • Omelets (with choice of Bagel/Bread)

    • 3-eggs, Mushrooms, Peppers, Onion

      $8

    • 3-eggs, Spinach, Tomato, Mozzarella

      $8

    • Cheese Omelet

      $7.50

      3 eggs, choice of cheese

    • Extra Add On:

      Add Extra Cheese - $2.50
      Additional Extra Meat - $4.00 
      Additional Extra Deli Meat/Turkey Bacon/Sausage - $6.00

    • Ham & Swiss

      $8.50

      3 eggs, choice of cheese

    • Vegetable Omelet

      $10.50

    • Western Omelets

      $9.50

      3 eggs, ham, peppers, onions & cheese

    • Egg Platters

      with Hash Browns & choice of Bread

    • 1-Egg Any Style

      $5.50

    • 2-Egg Any Style

      $6.50

    • 3-Eggs Any Style

      $7.50

    • For Bacon, Sausage, Scrapple, Taylor Ham or Boiled Ham

      $4

    • For Turkey Sausage, Turkey Bacon

      $6

    • Cold Cut Sandwiches

    • Cheese Sand

      Bagel: $6.50
      Wrap: $8
      Sub: $8

    • Extra Add On:

      Add Cheese to any sandwich - $2.50 (Cheese Choices: Provolone, Swiss, American, Mozzarella, or Pepper Jack)
      Add whole Jewish Style Pickle - $2.50

    • Genoa Salami

      Bagel: $8
      Wrap: $10.50
      Sub: $10.50

    • Ham

      Bagel: $8
      Wrap: $10.50
      Sub: $10.50

    • Italian Combo

      Bagel: $8.95
      Wrap: $10.95
      Sub: $10.95

    • Liverwurst

      Bagel: $6.50
      Wrap: $9
      Sub: $9

    • Pastrami

      Bagel: $8
      Wrap: $10.50
      Sub: $10.50

    • Roast Beef

      Bagel: $8
      Wrap: $10.50
      Sub: $10.50

    • Turkey

      Bagel: $8
      Wrap: $10.50
      Sub: $10.50

    • Wraps

    • Buffalo Chicken

      $12.95

      Grilled Chicken, hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, and blue cheese dressing

    • Chicken or Tuna Salad

      $10.95

      With lettuce, tomato and onion

    • Club Wrap

      $12.95

      Choice of roast beef, ham, or turkey with bacon letttuce, tomato, and mayo

    • Deli Special

      $9.95

      Corned beef or pastrami, swiss, cole slaw, and Russian dressing

    • Salads

    • Antipasto

      Small: $8.95
      Large: $10.95
      Capicola Ham, Genoa Salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, green pepper, onions, cucumbers, & olives

    • Chef's Salad

      Small: $8.95
      Large: $10.95
      Turkey, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, radishes, cucumbers, olives

    • Greek Salad

      Small: $8.95
      Large: $10.95
      Lettuce, tomato, feta cheese, onions, carrots, radishes, olives

    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      Small: $9.95
      Large: $12.95
      Grilled Chicken, lettuce, tomato, onions, carrots, radishes, olives

    • House Salad

      Small: $8.95
      Large: $10.95
      Choice of Chicken Salad or Tuna Salad lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers, carrots, radishes, olives

    • Regular Salad

      Small: $6.50
      Large: $8.50
      Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, carrots, radishes, & olives

    • Turkey Salad

      Small: $8.95
      Large: $10.95
      Turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, radishes, olives

    • Salad Sandwiches

      on bagel or bread

    • Chicken Salad

      $8.50

    • Egg Salad

      $7.50

    • Tuna Salad

      $8.50

    • From the Grill

    • B.L.T. on Bagel

      $7.95

    • Cheeseburger

      $9.50

    • Cheesesteak

      $9.50

      with a can soda - $11.00

    • Extra Add On:

      Add Hashbrowns to any Sandwich - $2

    • Grilled Cheese

      $6

      with bacon & tomato - $8.50

    • Grilled Chicken (Hero/Sub/Hoagie)

      $12.95

    • Hamburger

      $7.50

    • Reuben

      $10.95

      Pastrami, swiss cheese, Saurkraut & russian dressing on grilled Rye toast

    • Club Sandwiches

      Triple Decker Sandwiches w/ Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo, and Bacon

    • B.L.T. Club

      $9.95

    • Chicken Salad Club

      $9.95

    • Egg Salad Club

      $8.95

    • Pastrami Club

      $9.95

    • Roast Beef Club

      $9.95

    • Tuna Salad Club

      $9.95

    • Turkey Club

      $9.95

    • Baker's Choice Sandwiches

    • Big Bear

      $12.95

      Hot roast beef and provolone cheese w/ brown gravy on a hero roll

    • Big Dan

      $9.95

      Ham, melted swiss, honey mustard on a round roll

    • Bobby Cristo

      $9.95

      Grilled ham & turkey, melted Swiss and Russian dressing on grilled white bread

    • Dean's List

      $9.95

      Chicken salad, bacon, melted American cheese on onion bagel

    • Frank's Best

      $9.95

      Tuna, bacon, lettuce, and tomato on white toast

    • Irish Dennix

      $9.95

      Corned beef, swiss and spicy brown mustard on Rye bread

    • Iron Andy

      $9.95

      Turkey, muenster cheese, onions, and honey mustard on a plain bagel

    • Lady Di

      $9.95

      Hot Pastrami, melted swiss, and Russian dressing on grilled rye bread

    • Little Re

      $9.95

      Turkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato and mayo on a hero roll

    • Pizza Joe

      $12.95

      Grilled Chicken topped with tomato sauce, melted mozzarella cheese on a hero roll

    • Sea King

      $9.75

      Tuna Salad, melted American Cheese on a plain Bagel

    • The Butcher

      $11.95

      Roast beef, ham, turkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato and mayo on a hero roll

    • The Greek

      $9.95

      Turkey, swiss, cole slaw & Russian dressing on Rye bread

    • Cold Cuts

    • 3 Foot Sub

      $135.95

    • 4 Foot Sub

      $165.95

    • 6 Foot Sub

      $225.95

    • Party Bagel

      $8.50

      $8.50 / Per Person

    • Catering Trays

    • Bagels & Cream Cheese

      $4.25

      $4.25 / Per Person

    • Deluxe Tray

      $6

      $6 / Per Person

    • Sandwich Tray

      $8.95

      $8.95 / Per Person
      includes Pickles, Olives, and Condiments

New Castle Bagels

Freshly Baked, Always Delicious – Welcome to New Castle Bagels!

Directions

Address

Phone

Hours

  • Monday - Thursday: 5:00AM - 4:00PM
  • Friday: 5:00AM - 6:00PM
  • Saturday: 5:30AM - 3:00PM
  • Sunday: 6:00AM - 2:30PM
Directions
Scroll to Top